Very, and locate your own enneagram variety of, you initially must recognize you are unhealthy in some way or any other. » While you are an application step 1, you’re prideful; while a questionnaire dos you are lustful; etc. Declaring your enneatype is the same as announcing which psychological state you have fallen victim to.
Instantly, we see a-sharp contrast involving the enneagram while the MBTI. Even though it is true that Jung try a doctor whose works are mainly which have unhealthy clients, their model was however predicated on healthy somebody. Isabel Myers got Jung’s 7 « intellectual tastes, » broke up you to definitely model out from the rest of their composing, and created an instrument built to classify such compliment characters. The MBTI is certainly included in the latest areas regarding team, degree, and you may day-to-day lives as a way out of codifying typical man’s characters. There are not any worth judgments; no type of surpasses any other kind, neither could there be an effective « sinful » or « diseased » aspect of one identity sort of.
The complete thrust of one’s MBTI (basically from Keirsey’s attitude theory) is to try to pick identification designs which means helps communication and expertise ranging from anybody. It can be–and regularly is–misused so you’re able to identity people and you can foster bigotry; but that’s simply a punishment of one’s system you to definitely arises from lack of knowledge.
Very personally (except if I’m hopelessly in a state away from assertion), brand new enneagram is actually detrimental
The latest thrust of your own enneagram is always to select simple individual weaknesses otherwise failings (sins or identification conditions). Presented with its finest white, objective is to indicate below average members of the newest guidelines away from better health. However in any case, brand new initial step is, « There’s something completely wrong to you. » Buying towards that’s certain and then make a person feel defective. Furthermore, it is certain to make enneagram professional look for everybody else because faulty too. Towards the along with front side, that may help anyone undertake their unique and others’ rules and aim for worry about-update. However, into the downside they phone calls focus on man’s dark attributes; it emphasize brand new bad.
In my situation, it is far from an extremely of good use street chart
Just as very a good Christians stop preaching fire-and-brimstone, extremely enneagram followers stop in public discussing the deep section of the enneagram. Enneagram books and conversation organizations are full of laughs and you will friendly stories. Certain enneagram writers come across as optimistic because Dr. Phil. But one another Dr. Phil together with enneagram fundamentally run substandard thinking and you can behavior. The brand new logic is apparently, « if you aren’t unwell, we can’t improve you; thus earliest you must pick one off nine types of ailment. »
It might still be the great thing whether your enneagram was in fact capable develop individuals–however it are unable to. It is little more than a diagram that have associated descriptions from character at the varying levels of wellness. It may offer of good use yardsticks having treating schizophrenics or people with almost every other identification conditions; however, also people continue to be want to more let than simply this to really get well. The fresh enneagram is not a data recovery approach; it’s only a drawing–a sort of highway chart to help you recuperation.
Full, I would personally state I’m pretty darned healthy. I would have to stretch my creativeness and assume certain shadow regarding illness, next search for an approach to eradicate you to problem. At the same time, I am prone to end up being way more self-immersed, that is planning continue me of communicating with and you can insights anyone else while they are indeed.
Loaf around a keen enneagram conversation category for timeframe, and you might in the near future end up being you’re in a recuperation class. A few people need pleasure inside their enneatypes, but most recognize they have difficulties and are usually trying to get well out of those problems. While they are doing recover, most of them feel the enneagram won’t serve people of good use goal. Shortly after a guy gets vibrant, the latest enneagram gets irrelevant.